Journal of Syndromes
Download PDF
Case Report
Consequences of Lifting Heavy Weights in Marfan Syndrome and Concealment of Hereditary Disorders from Partners
Jargin SV
Department of Pathology, People’s Friendship University of Russia,
Russian Federation
*Address for Correspondence:Jargin SV, Department of Pathology, People’s Friendship University
of Russia, Clementovski per 6-82, 115184 Moscow, Russia, Email: sjargin@mail.ru
Submission:August 02, 2025
Accepted: August 27, 2025
Published: August 29, 2025
Copyright: © 2025 Jargin SV. This is an open access article
distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License,
which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction
in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Keywords:Marfan Syndrome; Heavy Weightlifting; Abdominal Wall
Prolapse; Hernia; Genetic Counseling; Inguinal Region
Abstract
Marfan syndrome (MS) is a genetic disorder with weakening of
connective tissue. Clinical manifestations include a wide range of
cardiovascular, ocular, and musculoskeletal derangements. The
case presented here describes consequences of belated diagnosis
of moderately expressed MS. Such cases may remain overlooked.
The case reports a 68-year-old patient with symptoms of MS and
corresponding family history, who presented with progressing prolapse
of lower abdominal wall, perineal descent, and foot edema. MS
was diagnosed at the age of over 30 years. Before that, the patient
worked in construction and was engaged in other activities, including
lifting of heavy weights. In conclusion, individuals with MS should avoid
heavy weight lifting. Concealment from a partner or spouse of a
known hereditary disorder may have consequences for the offspring.
Timely diagnosis of MS and genetic counseling of populations at risk is
important.
Introduction
“An individual feels ashamed when some undesirable truth about
one’s fundamental character is revealed to the self or others.” Sick
and unattractive people often appear as typical sufferers of shame
[1]. Besides, whistle-blowing and denunciation are often regarded as
shameful acts. On the contrary, many violators of laws and mores
do not experience any shame and emerge as winners. This pertains
to diverse phenomena: child and elder abuse [2,3], sexual and
reproductive coercion [4], various kinds of fraud and professional
misconduct in medicine [5,6]. For doctors, this applies to suboptimal
prescriptions due to conflicts of interest, let alone invasive procedures
without sufficient indications [6]. What can be done to route the
emotion of shame in the right direction, so that not the victims and
whistleblowers but the perpetrators would be ashamed? Publications
with names and references seem to be the best way.
In a milieu tolerating sexual and reproductive coercion, where
sexually transmitted infections (STI) or hereditary diseases are
concealed from potential partners, such conditions cease to be a
private matter. In case of the latter, this pertains also to the kinship.
In the author’s opinion, the contraceptive sabotage must be regarded
as offence with infliction of bodily harm if an abortion or unwanted
pregnancy, STI or genetic disease has been inflicted [4]. In particular,
concealment from a partner or spouse of a known hereditary disorder
may have grave consequences. Of note, STI are usually curable but
genetic diseases are generally not. This gives to a medical professional
a moral right in some cases to disregard the obligation to secrecy,
when it can be reasonably assumed that of the offender, his or her
relatives would continue spreading abnormal genotype. Fortunately,
genetic testing and counseling are rapidly evolving [7,8]; so that the
above considerations may be revised one day.
Case report
Marfan syndrome (MS) is a disorder with weakness of connective
tissue, inherited according to the autosomal dominant pattern,
having variable penetrance. There is abundant literature about MS;
and the symptoms are generally known. This case report illustrates
late consequences of lifting heavy weights by an individual with
belated diagnosis of moderately expressed MS. The patients are
discouraged from heavy weightlifting, contact sports (rugby, boxing),
high G-force activities and deep-sea diving. However, most of them
may engage in athletic and other physical activities with moderate
load. At the same time, it was noticed that there is little real-world
data to support the lifestyle recommendations [9].
The family history of S. illustrated the psychological mechanism
“like will to like”, which can facilitate marriages between people
with related hereditary conditions. Other people would perceive an
abnormality, but a person somewhat similar to oneself might provoke
interest and sympathy. This is potentially dangerous for the offspring.
Both his parents were ethnic Russians. The mother had moderately
expressed marfanoid appearance. The father was tall with the head
circumference ~61 cm, otherwise nondescript. However, his sister
and daughter from his first marriage both had marfanoid body
structure. S. had moderately expressed symptoms of MS: tall stature,
thin skeleton with lax joints, moderate arachnodactyly, pes planus
and slight kyphosis diagnosed in childhood. From adolescence on, S.
heard comments about his “feebleness” and overcompensated this by
some sports: rowing, backpacker tourism, fitness training including
weightlifting. Starting at the age of 18 years, he repeatedly participated
in construction and forestry works during holydays, totaled to 3 years
plus 2 years of army service. These activities included lifting of heavy
weights. Marfan syndrome was not diagnosed at yearly checkups
(dispensarizations) neither at the Sechenov Medical Academy,
where S. studied and was employed in the period 1973-1990, nor at
other institutions. Hereditary diseases have not been given sufficient
attention in the above-named Academy [6]. The diagnosis was
first suspected at the age over 30 years, when S. already had visible
asymmetry of the inguinal region. At the age of 66 years, along with
atrophy of abdominal muscles, S. developed prolapse of his lower
abdominal wall and descensus perinei with foot edema predominantly
on left side (Figures 1,2). He can sleep only keeping his lower limbs
apart e.g. with a balloon ~40 cm in diameter between his thighs,
otherwise circulation disturbances in the limbs become perceptible
due to perineal descent with compression of blood vessels. Besides,
he has a hiatal hernia and radiologically confirmed old compressive
fracture of the C6 vertebral body with recurrent pains and symptoms
of vertebrobasilar insufficiency. Emergence of the fracture coincided
with heavy weight lifting during construction works at the age of 29
years [10].
The vertebral injury mentioned above should be further
commented. In 1985-1986 the construction job was helping to finish
a stadium in a city north of St. Petersburg. Temporary workers were
employed because of the short construction period, for which the
regular staff did not suffice. They worked on average 16 hours a day
without holidays, making concrete works and doing other tasks. The
vertebral column sent feedback through the afferent channels: he
should not carry heavy weights. The barrow became heavier, and the
pain in the spine got worse. It started to hurt again 12 years later, in the
cervical area, when S. practiced abroad as a pathologist and started to
go on long-distance bicycle trips to counteract the sedentary lifestyle.
At first, it was difficult to turn his head changing traffic lanes; the pain
later became almost permanent, forcing him to get off the bicycle and
walk. The conclusion, after radiography, was: old compressive fracture
of the C6 vertebral body. S. had to avoid any load on the shoulder
girdle. The barrow was overloaded by the temporary team-leader
(Dmitrii Iosifovich Gotlib). S. had a visibly thin skeleton; the barrow
was too heavy for him, but he had difficulties with saying “No”; and
surrounding persons knew this. Gotlib originated from a privileged
Soviet family. He has pectus excavatum and treated epilepsy, which
he concealed from his wife (divorced after a nocturnal grand mal) and
the Khrzhizhanovsky Power Engineering Institute, where he worked
with sources of radiation (dismissed in the 1990s, later worked in
construction). Epilepsy has a strong genetic predisposition [11].
As for pectus excavatum, it is known to be part of various genetic
syndromes [12]. Besides, Gotlib was noticed to damage Siberian
Forest, working in pine tree tapping [13].
Discussion
Many cases are known when a heritable disease was concealed
from the partner and then acquired by the offspring. For example, 20-
25% people from certain East- and mid-European Jewish descent carry
certain disease-causing genes. Approximately one in 10-15 Ashkenazi
Jewish individuals are carriers of a mutation causing type 1 Gaucher
disease, 1/30 – familial dysautonomia, 1/75 – A or B type of Niemann-
Pick disease; 1/40 are estimated to be carriers for Canavan disease,
1/89 - Fanconi anemia [14]. The prevalence of various conditions is
above-average in the above-mentioned population: diabetes mellitus,
some solid cancers and leukemias, certain ophthalmic and disorders;
more details and references are in the article [15] and in the handbook
[9]. Screening of the European Jewish population for recessive
disease-causing mutations is recommended; one grandparent suffices
to offer a genetic examination [16]. Israel plays an important role
in the development of genetic counseling: more than 10,000 people
are tested there every year [17]. “Do not have children unless you
are sure that they will be healthy both mentally and physically” [17].
This suggestion is not realizable in conditions of sexual coercion,
contraceptive sabotage or concealment of a heritable disease from the
partner or spouse.
Many mutations are not specific but tend to be accumulated by the
above-named population [18,19]. The problematic heredity may give
rise to conscious or subconscious motives to look for partners from
different ethnic backgrounds. Various tools can be applied: seduction
and persuasion, intimidation and force, alcohol and drugs. Women
should be aware of these tactics. The sexual and reproductive coercion
has been used for the purpose of migration, to cement relationships
and marriages, to obtain a residence permit and lodging, or to spread
a certain genotype often with geopolitical motives. This is a probable
cause of increased birthrates immediately after immigration [20].
Another case observed by the author: a young individual of
Jewish descent (Aleksandr Kantsedikas [AK], lithuanization of
the name Kohen-Tsadok or Cohen-Tsedek), who wanted to live in
Moscow, concealed a hereditary condition from his 13 years older
ethnic Russian bride. There were three medical doctors among
near relatives of AK; his congenital abnormalities were known
and discussed. He had a male Stein-Leventhal alias polycystic
ovary syndrome (PCOS) equivalent, possibly combined with other
derangements: gynecomastia and hypertrichosis, polythelia and
inclination to overweight. Male PCOS was defined as a syndrome
with signs of hyperandrogenism, PCOS-like metabolic pattern and
familiar history of PCOS [21,22]. His daughter inherited PCOS and
died in her fifties. AK was involved in child abuse and sexual violence
[4]; he approvingly discussed with his father Solomon, the World
War II veteran and retired colonel [23,24], the torture of prisoners of
war, using among others the phrases like “some Jewish guys could not
control themselves”. Sons of some of high-ranking officers have been
a known problem in the ex-Soviet society being involved in immoral
and illegal activities, professional misconduct [5,6] etc. High social
positions held by perpetrators or their relatives prevented reporting.
Another example has been published previously: a promiscuous
son of a Soviet general knowingly spreading STI [25]. The case was
reported to authorities, and the whistleblower beaten at a later date
[6]. At the same time, many young relatives of superior officers,
including all those mentioned in this report, evaded the mandatory
military service under various pretexts [4,24].
A vice versa case was also observed: a female postgraduate
student of Baltic origin with marfanoid body structure married a
Jewish department head; both their children inherited marfanoid
appearance. Another example: a young male concealed type 1
diabetes mellitus from his older ethnic Russian bride; their daughter
developed the same condition plus obesity at the age of ~25 years,
when her father had already been dead.
In cases of sexual and reproductive coercion, contraceptive
sabotage and family violence, it may be easy to expose a socially
unprotected perpetrator. Otherwise, different tools can be used
to prevent a disclosure: denial of facts and accusation of slander,
threats and violence, tricks and provocations, appeals to uphold the
honor and reputation of an institution, family, ethnic or confessional
community. Some relatives of high-ranking officers or functionaries
continue the misconduct, serving as models for the rising generation.
Such cases may need administrative support and should be reported
to the authorities.
Conclusion
MS has variable penetrance [9]. This means that there are many
people with moderately expressed symptoms; but their connective
tissue is weakened [26]. Furthermore, individuals with marfanoid
phenotype may be carriers of disease-causing genes, needing genetic
counseling. This is of particular importance when a person with
marfanoid features finds a life partner with a similar stature. Not all
of such individuals should be diagnosed with MS, but they need an
examination and advice concerning occupational choice, physical
activities and procreation. Most importantly, patients with MS must
avoid heavy weight lifting. Genetic counseling should be broader
applied in high-risk groups. Screening of Ashkenazi population
for disease-causing mutations is recommended; one grandparent
suffices to offer a genetic examination. More attention should be
given to hereditary conditions at medical checkups and in the course
of medical education. Concealment from a partner or spouse of a
known hereditary disorder may have grave consequences. This gives
to a medical professional a moral right to disregard the obligation to
secrecy, when it can be reasonably assumed that of the offender, his or
her relatives would continue spreading abnormal genotype.
References
1. Shaughnessy MJ (2018) Integrative literature review on shame. Nursing Science Quarterly 31: 86-94.