Journal of Environmental Studies
Download PDF
Research Article
Environmental Damage and Overpopulation: Demographic Aspects
Jargin SV*
Department of Pathology, People’s Friendship University of Russia, Russian Federation, Russia
*Address for Correspondence:
Jargin SV, Department of Pathology, People’s Friendship University of
Russia, Clementovski per 6-82, 115184 Moscow, Russia, Tel: 7 495
9516788; E-mail: sjargin@mail.ru
Submission: 26 August, 2021;
Accepted: 28 September 2021;
Published: 05 October 2021
Copyright: © 2021 Jargin SV. This is an open access article distributed
under the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits
unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided
the original work is properly cited.
Abstract
Environmental damage is proportional to the population density.
The overpopulation leads to a shortage of fresh water and food in
many regions. Smoldering international conflicts provide motives for the
population growth. The necessity of birth control has been obfuscated
by conflicting national and global interests, the population growth
being regarded as a tool helping to the sovereignty and national
defense. Several regions with a relative overpopulation, actual or
potential conflicts are discussed here. Today, when common interests
of the humankind are becoming obvious, the introduction of new
moral principles is needed. One of such principles is that a birth rate of
an ethnic minority should not be higher than that of the main nation of
a country. Social consequences of gender imbalance must be borne
mainly by those population groups, where sex-selective abortions are
practiced. Recognition of these principles can become a basis for the
international trust and cooperation.
Introduction
All kinds of environmental damage are proportional to the
population density [1]
. The overpopulation is a principal reason
for the shortage of fresh water and food. In the last quarter of the
20th century, population grew faster in developing than in highincome
countries, while, compared to the population growth, an
increase in carbon emissions grew faster in developing countries
than in high-income ones [2]
. In the past, overpopulation has been
reduced by homicide, epidemics and starvation. Today, there is a
possibility to apply humane, scientifically based methods, consciously
choosing between the birth rate restriction and mortality rise.
Surgical sterilization is the most reliable method of birth control;
it was applied in India in the 1970s, but later these measures have
been rolled back. The one-child policy in China was successful, but
has been dismantled. Appeals can be hard to completely abolish the
family planning and birth control in China[3]
.
Countries receiving immigrants decide whom they admit and
whom not. Sterilization can be taken into account making decisions
about residence and work permits. The male sterilization (vasectomy)
is a simple and harmless procedure. The female sterilization (tubal
ligation) can be performed without additional trauma at a birth by
cesarean section. A more frequent use of cesarean tubal ligation
would be especially favorable for overpopulated regions with a
gender imbalance [4]. Certainly, surgical sterilization can be seen as
a violation of the bodily integrity. The same, however, can be said
about sexual and reproductive coercion sometimes committed for
migration/accommodation purposes or to spread a certain genotype,
with conscious or subconscious geopolitical motives (discussed
below).
Overpopulation and gender imbalance:
Logically, rapidly growing population groups should live in less
spacious conditions. Consequences of the gender imbalance must be
borne by the populations with imbalance due to immigration and/
or sex-selective abortions. The recognition of these principles can
become a basis for the international understanding and trust. In
consideration of ecological and economic conditions, an optimal
fertility level should be recommended for different regions. Who
will determine the level? Primarily, everybody, for her or himself. In
a country with sufficient water resources, the birth rate of the main
nation can be higher than in a desert, where inhabitants consume
desalinated water and foodstuff acquired for the foreign aid and/or oil
revenues. An international organization could issue evidence-based
recommendations [5].Among the mechanisms leading to the gender imbalance are sexselective
abortions [6]. In accordance with traditions, economical
and social motives, many families prefer to have sons. A gender
imbalance among the newborn has been reported from China, India
and some neighboring countries, from the Caucasus as well as the
immigrant milieu in the United States and Europe [7-9]. Migrations
contribute to the gender imbalance: the shortage of males creates
additional motives for sex-selective abortions in the emigration
countries. In Russia, considerable gender imbalance is observed
among immigrants. According to the 2014 census, the male/female
ratio in the Crimea, among ethnic Russians was 0.85, Tatars – 0.98,
Armenians – 1.3, Karaites – 1.3, Krymchaks – 1.4 [10]. The following
male/female ratios among newborns were reported for the period
2015-2020: Azerbaijan – 113, China – 113, Armenia – 111, India –
110, Albania – 109 [11]. Evaluating statistics, it should be taken into
account that the gender imbalance is veiled by shorter life duration of
males. In the Russian Federation, the imbalance with predominance
of men of working ages is superseded by prevail of women in the
retirement age [12]. Obviously, the social significance of gender
imbalance is decreasing with age. Official statistics based on censes
tend to underestimate the gender imbalance as predominantly males
are involved in migrations, some of them remaining uncounted by
censes. Social programs supporting families with girls are supposed to be expensive and difficult to implement [1]. Prohibitive measures
against sex-selective abortions may be not sufficiently effective as they
would stimulate such “traditional” methods of demographic control
as female neonaticide and neglect of newborn girls [6,13,14]. The predominance of males is more conspicuous in lower socio-economic
classes; their marginalization may lead to antisocial behavior. As
the excess of men may cause insecurity, families would be further
motivated to have sons for protection. The growing excess of men may
contribute to militarism and international conflicts. Furthermore, a
mechanism maintaining the highest birth rate and son preference is
related to the insufficient public assistance. Ageing people depend on
their children for support, while sons and their families are supposed
to be better caregivers than daughters at least in some cultures [15].
An improvement of the social security in developing countries must
positively influence the demographic processes.
Ethnic transformations:
In the past, the high birth rate was used to support national
independence. Even today, a large population is sometimes seen as
a guarantee of sovereignty. Birth rate inequalities result in minorities
becoming majorities, which can cause local conflicts. An example
is Kosovo, where the Albanian majority developed as a result of
the immigration and higher birth rate [16,17]. Similarly to ethnic
Russians in some parts of the former Soviet Union (fSU), Serbs are
leaving Kosovo. Within fSU, the most significant changes have been
observed in the Caucasus and Central Asia. The emigration of ethnic
Russians from these regions started several decades ago and increased
after the dissolution of the fSU. The immigration to Russia from
Central Asia is growing. In the North Caucasus, absolute numbers
and percentages of ethnic Russians are decreasing both in urban and
rural areas. The maximal birth rates in the Russian Federation have
been recorded in Ingushetia, Chechnya, Tuva and Dagestan; while
the population is decreasing most rapidly in Tambov, Tver, Tula and
Pskov provinces [18]. There is a continuous migration of Chechens
from the mountainous to plain areas to the North of the Caucasian
Mountains. Per capita incomes in the North Caucasus lag behind
the population growth [19]. The Armenian minority is growing in
Stavropol and Krasnodar provinces, especially in the Caucasian
Riviera (Black Sea coast), where they have massively participated in
privatization and construction of houses [20]. In the above-named
provinces, percentages of North-Caucasian ethnicities, Armenians
and Romani people are growing while ethnic Russians are leaving
[21]. Migration distances are increasing: from the Caucasus and
Middle Asia to Moscow, Königsberg-Kaliningrad, Siberia and the Far
East [22]. In all provinces of the Russian Far East (except Yakutia),
the ethnic Russian population decreased during the period 2002-
2010. Since 2000, migration to the Far East and Siberia from Central
Asia and China has been increasing. During the period 2002-2010,
the number of Tajiks in the Far East increased 2.3 times, Uzbeks –
3.4, Kyrgyz – 3.8 times [23]. The population growth in the Russian
Far East has been maximal in Buryatia and Yakutia (Sakha) Republics
thanks to higher birth rates of the indigenous ethnic groups [24].In this connection, the Jewish question must be briefly tackled.
As discussed above, to prevent ethnic conflicts, minorities should
not grow more rapidly than the main nation of a country. This is
understood in many Jewish families. However, in the conservative
milieu the birth rate remains relatively high. In some cities e.g. New
York the Jewish population is considerable. After the World War
II, people of Jewish descent had a possibility to lead a normal life
almost everywhere. Evidently, a moderation in the birth rate has been
advisable. The migration to the populated territory with a shortage of
fresh water and energy resources occurred after individual decisions
of the migrants. Since 1948, the population of Israel increased from
850 thousands to >9 million people [25]. The militarized society
has deprived a part of the ex-Soviet intelligentsia of their hoped-for
perspectives [26]. Each migrant to Palestine could realize that he
or she was going, directly or indirectly, to take possession of other
people’s property and to live partly at the expenses of the foreign
help, mainly from the United States and Germany. Moreover, the
ethnic discrimination in the German immigration policy should be
mentioned. It sufficed to declare oneself a Jew to obtain an unlimited
residence permit and social assistance. In this way, other foreigners
are discriminated: after many years of work they have to leave the
country. Some refugees live for social benefits years-long. The welfare
agency (Sozialamt) is regarded as a club for selected public, where
the wealth is distributed: regular cash payments, apartments, medical
and pension insurance, free education, etc. Conversations of this kind
about Sozialamt can be heard in an upscale restaurant or a consular
office, where these refugees are inviting to Germany their relatives
and friends. Some refugees are engaged in more or less legal business
evading taxes. Apartments paid by the Sozialamt are sometimes
subleased. Despite legal and moral barriers, many refugees of this
kind travel to their former homeland in the fSU. There are cases
when the refugees rented out their Moscow apartments, or when a
paterfamilias operated a business in Russia, while the family lived
in Germany for the welfare benefits. The Camp David Accords have
been an efficient tool to acquire foreign aid. Israel has been the largest
cumulative recipient of the U.S. foreign assistance since the World
War II [27]. After the Camp David Accords, American aid to Egypt
increased considerably. Apparently, some former adversaries in the
Middle-Eastern conflicts acted to the mutual benefit. There seems
to be a more or less covert alliance between certain spheres on both
sides, while the set of ideas, prevalent also in some other places of the
Middle East, Caucasus and Central Asia, includes the high natality,
migrations and, wherever tolerated, reproductive coercion [28]. A
solution for Palestine, Syria and some adjacent territories could be a
protectorate by developed nations with the aim to preserve as much
human life and wealth as possible, to ensure equality and safety, to curb
the population growth in the desert, stimulated by the long-lasting
conflict[5]. The agricultural farming in conditions of insufficient
fresh water and energy resources is environmentally unfriendly and
economically disadvantageous as imported fossil fuels are burnt for
the desalination. If peace in the Middle East would be guaranteed,
the problem of the energy supply for water desalination could be
largely solved by nuclear power plants. The foreign aid is currently
wasted for military purposes. There are no alternatives to the nuclear
energy today [29]. In the long run, non-renewable fossil fuels will
become more expensive, contributing to the population growth in oil
producing regions and poverty elsewhere. Nuclear power has come
back to the agenda due to concerns about increasing global energy
demand and climate changes. Health burdens are greatest for power
stations based on coal and oil. The burdens are smaller for natural gas and still lower for nuclear power. The same ranking applies also to the greenhouse gas emissions and thus probably to climate changes
[30]. Obviously, peace and international trust are needed for a safe
development of the nuclear industry.
Sexual and Reproductive Coercion:
Migrants are partly criminalized; in particular, sexual and
reproductive coercion (RC) are known to occur, sometimes applied
deliberately for migration purposes. Reportedly, about 70% of rapes in
Moscow have been committed by immigrants from Central Asia[31].
Certain other minorities have been active as well. RC interferes with
a woman’s decision-making about reproduction; it may consist of
contraception sabotage and/or pressure to carry a pregnancy to term.
RC is not always understood as such by the victim; in particular, the
intimate partner violence (IPV) may prevent a woman from naming
certain behaviors as coercion; details and references are in [28]. In the
author’s opinion, the criminal justice should handle the neglectful and
intentional contraception sabotage in and out of wedlock as a crime
with infliction of bodily harm if an abortion or unintended pregnancy
followed. Several case histories have been discussed in the preceding
paper in connection with the topic of this article [28]. Certain cases
were reported to the authorities after a delay as the denunciation of
illegal and immoral acts was unusual in FSU, especially if committed
by individuals from the privileged milieu. In some cultural settings
with a rape myth acceptance, sexual violence has been a method of
acquiring wives [32,33]. The fact that some victims married their
rapists was erroneously seen as indication that women enjoy it; in
fact, existing accounts demonstrate various degrees of trauma [33].
In this connection, it is important to detect the violent entrapment
or “battered woman syndrome” including the learned helplessness
[34,35]. Among potential contributing factors are the machismo
ideology, disrespect for laws and regulations, impunity of some
offenses and offenders. It should be mentioned that in certain ethnicsocial
milieus boys may be instructed within their families. Sexual
experiences with relatives are not unusual in chaotic environments
[36]. It was reported that 49% of the “child perpetrators” had been
sexually abused prior to their own abusive behaviors [37]. It can be reasonably assumed that the social progress would
correlate with improvements of morality. However, international
migrations confound this scheme, while the alcohol-related neglect of
contraception gives way to migration-related and geopolitical motives
[5]. The reproductive coercion is sometimes used to spread a certain
genotype or to cement a marriage contracted to obtain a residence
permit and/or lodging. The latter may be one of the mechanisms
of birth rate elevation noticed immediately after immigration
[38,39]. Cases are known when a potentially heritable disease (type
1 diabetes mellitus, male Stein-Leventhal, Marfan syndrome etc.) in
a perpetrator was concealed from the partner and then acquired by
offspring. Various methods are applied: seduction and persuasion
up to hypnosis, alcohol and drugs, intimidation and IPV [28,40].
Considering the forthcoming globalization, women should be aware
of these strategies. As mentioned in the Introduction, sterilization
may be a workable solution especially for males incapable or unwilling
to control their behavior and consistently use condoms, although it
does not prevent STI. Vasectomy is a safe and efficient method of
permanent contraception, it is obviously preferable to abortion and
unwanted pregnancy; details and references are in [28]. In regard to the tubal ligation, its combination with cesarean section (CS) i.e.
cesarean tubal ligation should be considered by women not planning
further pregnancies. In the author’s opinion, CS on maternal request
must be available in the absence of medical contraindications for
vaginal delivery. In particular, this pertains to Russia, where CS is
usually not performed on a maternal request [41]. Considering the
global overpopulation, the worldwide increase in the CS rate is a
favorable development especially in overpopulated regions [4].Discussion and Conclusion
The workforce productivity is growing; few workers can provide
a means of subsistence for many people while unemployment is
growing. In the past, similar developments were interrupted by wars
or pestilence. This has not happened long since; we are waiting to
see what happens while the global population is increasing. However,
there are many things to do. Great projects could be accomplished
to improve the life of billions: irrigation facilities for droughtstricken
lands, worldwide development of nuclear and other energy
sources as alternatives to fossil hydrocarbons. Scientific research
should be revitalized, purged of falsification and tendentiousness
due to commercial interests or ideological bias [42]. Such efforts
would create work for many people. The necessity of birth control
has been obfuscated by conflicting national and global interests: the
population growth has been seen as a tool helping the sovereignty
and economic advance of developing countries. Smoldering conflicts
provide further motivation for the population growth, in particular,
in the regions with a shortage of fresh water and energy resources
[5]. An international authority based in developed countries could
counteract the growing overpopulation and environmental damage.
Most importantly, people must learn to trust each other.