Food Circles : Envisioning How Eating a Variety of Foods Over Time will Benefit Health

Confronted with the quandary regarding specific nutritional recommendations, a hypothetical diversified diet is envisioned. A Venn diagram, in which each circle represents a separate food, is used to visualize how eating a variety of foods will optimize the nutritive value of a diet by complementing or synergizing nutrients from different foods and by diluting concentrations of individual dysnutrients. Eating a variety of foods may be viewed as a distinctive dietary pattern in itself, lending itself to investigation in comparison to other dietary patterns. A diversified diet over time should outperform the existing dietary types with respect to health benefits because available dietary models are not sufficiently diversified and include foods favored only for historical, geographic, and cultural reasons, and such foods may contain dysnutrients that could be injurious to health. Nutritional Quandary Nutrition is complex and is influenced by geography (climate, soil conditions), evolutionary genetic patterns, societal norms, influence of the food industry, and several other variables [1,2]. Nutritional deficits affect the causation and progression of a host of diseases [3], but specific nutritional factors are known only for cardiovascular disease. Although one can choose a diet geared toward improving cardiovascular markers such as lipid profile, no such dietary factors exist for cancers, Alzheimer’s disease, or a multitude of other diseases. Even cardiovascular markers do not reliably predict disease and may provide a sense of false security; for example, a high level of socalled good, high-density lipoprotein cholesterol may not necessarily defend against the occurrence of cardiovascular disease [4]. Contrary to the last half century of nutritional science, the recent discovery that atherosclerosis existed in premodern human beings across four diverse preindustrial populations infers that atherosclerosis may not be related to any particular modern lifestyle or dietary pattern [5]. To further complicate matters, it is extremely challenging for laypersons and experts alike to make sense of the frequent conflicting medical reports and industry claims of the benefits or adverse effects of various food products, which results in an admonition to “take nutrition claims with a grain of salt” [6]. In essence, we do not know how to accurately target our eating to prevent disease or to slow down the effects of aging. One Hypothetical Solution Given the quandary regarding specific nutritional recommendations, it makes sense to eat a variety of foods. The proposed hypothesis is two-fold. First, no single food will meet all the nutritional requirements of the human body. Second, every food may contain something undesirable, or a “dysnutrient”. Dysnutrients, a new term to my knowledge, are broadly defined here as unhealthful substances such as toxins, poisons, or allergens that are present in a food either by nature, intention, or otherwise. Exposition of the Hypothesis Envisioning eating variety in terms of food circles I have used a Venn diagram (Figure 1), in which each circle represents a separate food, to illustrate how eating a variety of foods will optimize the nutritive value of a diet. This is achieved by (a) complementing and/or synergizing nutrients from different foods, and (b) diluting concentrations of potential individual dysnutrients. Fundamentally, many of the foods we consume in Western societies are far from ideal from a nutritional standpoint, yet we often become satisfied with a certain type of diet and so maintain it. Many dysnutrients from the perspective of humans are actually substances that protect plants from predators. We should, therefore, avoid overconsumption of these dysnutrients by increasing the range of foods we eat. Consuming a variety of foods may be safer and may even promote well-being, because a diverse diet might also satisfy one’s emotional needs [7]. If we delete the stippled lines in Figure 1a, we obtain Figure 1b. Note the two cloverleaves—one within the other—in Figure 1b; the inner cloverleaf represents the union of nutrients from all foods present in a meal. These cloverleaves will eventually be transformed into two concentric circles if we continue to add circles by increasing the different foods we eat, with an infinite array of foods resulting in perfect circles. We may want to picture the food circles alongside the well-known food pyramid, because mindful eating may make a measurable difference in terms of body weight and longevity. Clearly, my proposed diagram is necessarily simple or “primitive” in comparison to the frequently updated and altered food pyramid and other visual displays of healthful eating, because it is intended to illustrate a single critical concept. Example of a diversified diet The concept of food circles may be compared, for example, to combining chemotherapy drugs for which the therapeutic effects of several drugs that act on different targets are maximized and the non-overlapping side effects are minimized. To put it in day-to-day parlance, one should diversify his or her food portfolio just as one Beerelli Seshi* Los Angeles Biomedical Research Institute at Harbor-UCLA Medical Center, Torrance, California, USA *Address for Correspondence Beerelli Seshi, M.D., 8538 Villa La Jolla Dr, Unit 188, La Jolla, CA 92037, USA, Tel: (310) 971-1810; E-mail: BSeshi@labiomed.org Submission: 12 December 2014 Accepted: 24 December 2014 Published: 29 December 2014 Reviewed & Approved by: Dr. Harold H. Fain, Assistant Professor of Community Medicine, University of North Texas Health Science Center, USA Review Article Open Access Journal of Integrative Medicine & Therapy Avens Publishing Group Inviting Innovations Avens Publishing Group Inviting Innovations Citation: Seshi B. Food Circles: Envisioning How Eating a Variety of Foods Over Time will Benefit Health. J Integrative Med Ther. 2014;1(1): 3. J Integrative Med Ther 1(1): 3 (2014) Page 02 ISSN: 2378-1343 would diversify a financial portfolio to minimize risk and improve the return. Thus, our complex bodies require a complex set of nutritional elements that can only be provided by eating a variety of whole foods. A safe approach may be to consume a diversified diet comprising well-balanced and nutritious foods to ensure that systems other than the cardiovascular system are well taken care of, and consequently diseases influenced by diet may be prevented or ameliorated. A diversified diet may consist of, for example seven different grains, seven different vegetables, seven different fruits, and so on, distributed over a week. Bringing such a diet to the table is as easy or difficult as cooking any other diet, which is limited not only by planning but also expense (i.e., income/budget) and availability. Emerging evidence for food synergy Food synergy, the idea that eating two foods together is more beneficial than eating either food alone, is a rapidly advancing field [8]. The concept, however, seems to have been in practice for a long time. For example, since ancient times, people in every culture have eaten some combination of beans and grains, the proteins from which are complementary in terms of amino acids [9]. Plant foods contain the full complement of essential amino acids, but at varying levels. It is also well known that curcumin, the bioactive compound present in turmeric root, has a limited bioavailability if consumed alone in tablet form [10]. On the other hand, its absorption is greatly enhanced if eaten together with black pepper [11] or yogurt [12] or in curry form [13]. The antioxidant property of oat phenolics is synergistically improved by ascorbic acid [14]. A combination of tomato and broccoli was shown to be more effective at slowing tumor growth than either tomato or broccoli alone [15]. Finally, evidence is accumulating that specific combinations of phytochemicals may offer better protection against cancer than single compounds (see Ref [16] for review). Eventually, as the knowledge regarding the interactions of various foods is expanded, the underlying mechanisms will be elucidated. Ultimately, as guidebooks map the food-food-body interactions (what may be referred to as “food interactomics”), intelligent diversified diets with targeted objectives can be developed. Comparative view of a diverse diet vs. traditional diets Considering food synergy, a well-planned and diversified diet will likely have health benefits over time [8]. If this is the case, one may speculate about the health benefits of a diverse diet in comparison with the health effects of well-known dietary models, such as mediterranean, asian, and western diets [17]. There may exist as many ethnic dietary or culinary models as the number of regions, perhaps even as many as the number of countries in the world. Each such diet may have signature foods unique to a region that offer distinctive health benefits and/or contribute to particular health issues. Existing dietary models have evolved over hundreds or thousands of years for a variety of historical, geographical, and cultural reasons, and thus each such diet has its favored foods. In contrast, one could envision a programmatic diversified diet consisting of a broad food portfolio. Analogous to a diversified financial portfolio, the varied diet is predicted to outperform existing dietary models in health benefits over time. To my knowledge, no specific diversified diet has ever been devised or tested vis-à-vis the classical dietary models. The proposed comparisons should open avenues of research asking for a variety of testable questions seeking to provide answers not only in terms of available laboratory tests such as cardiovascular markers, but also personal happiness, quality of living, long-term health benefits, and the consequent overall health care costs. Figure 1: Concept of food circles. Each circle represents a separate food, as it enables application of the power 


Nutritional Quandary
Nutrition is complex and is influenced by geography (climate, soil conditions), evolutionary genetic patterns, societal norms, influence of the food industry, and several other variables [1,2].Nutritional deficits affect the causation and progression of a host of diseases [3], but specific nutritional factors are known only for cardiovascular disease.Although one can choose a diet geared toward improving cardiovascular markers such as lipid profile, no such dietary factors exist for cancers, Alzheimer's disease, or a multitude of other diseases.Even cardiovascular markers do not reliably predict disease and may provide a sense of false security; for example, a high level of socalled good, high-density lipoprotein cholesterol may not necessarily defend against the occurrence of cardiovascular disease [4].Contrary to the last half century of nutritional science, the recent discovery that atherosclerosis existed in premodern human beings across four diverse preindustrial populations infers that atherosclerosis may not be related to any particular modern lifestyle or dietary pattern [5].To further complicate matters, it is extremely challenging for laypersons and experts alike to make sense of the frequent conflicting medical reports and industry claims of the benefits or adverse effects of various food products, which results in an admonition to "take nutrition claims with a grain of salt" [6].In essence, we do not know how to accurately target our eating to prevent disease or to slow down the effects of aging.

One Hypothetical Solution
Given the quandary regarding specific nutritional recommendations, it makes sense to eat a variety of foods.The proposed hypothesis is two-fold.First, no single food will meet all the nutritional requirements of the human body.Second, every food may contain something undesirable, or a "dysnutrient".Dysnutrients, a new term to my knowledge, are broadly defined here as unhealthful substances such as toxins, poisons, or allergens that are present in a food either by nature, intention, or otherwise.

Exposition of the Hypothesis Envisioning eating variety in terms of food circles
I have used a Venn diagram (Figure 1), in which each circle represents a separate food, to illustrate how eating a variety of foods will optimize the nutritive value of a diet.This is achieved by (a) complementing and/or synergizing nutrients from different foods, and (b) diluting concentrations of potential individual dysnutrients.Fundamentally, many of the foods we consume in Western societies are far from ideal from a nutritional standpoint, yet we often become satisfied with a certain type of diet and so maintain it.Many dysnutrients from the perspective of humans are actually substances that protect plants from predators.We should, therefore, avoid overconsumption of these dysnutrients by increasing the range of foods we eat.Consuming a variety of foods may be safer and may even promote well-being, because a diverse diet might also satisfy one's emotional needs [7].If we delete the stippled lines in Figure 1a, we obtain Figure 1b.Note the two cloverleaves-one within the other-in Figure 1b; the inner cloverleaf represents the union of nutrients from all foods present in a meal.These cloverleaves will eventually be transformed into two concentric circles if we continue to add circles by increasing the different foods we eat, with an infinite array of foods resulting in perfect circles.We may want to picture the food circles alongside the well-known food pyramid, because mindful eating may make a measurable difference in terms of body weight and longevity.Clearly, my proposed diagram is necessarily simple or "primitive" in comparison to the frequently updated and altered food pyramid and other visual displays of healthful eating, because it is intended to illustrate a single critical concept.

ISSN: 2378-1343
would diversify a financial portfolio to minimize risk and improve the return.Thus, our complex bodies require a complex set of nutritional elements that can only be provided by eating a variety of whole foods.A safe approach may be to consume a diversified diet comprising well-balanced and nutritious foods to ensure that systems other than the cardiovascular system are well taken care of, and consequently diseases influenced by diet may be prevented or ameliorated.A diversified diet may consist of, for example seven different grains, seven different vegetables, seven different fruits, and so on, distributed over a week.Bringing such a diet to the table is as easy or difficult as cooking any other diet, which is limited not only by planning but also expense (i.e., income/budget) and availability.

Emerging evidence for food synergy
Food synergy, the idea that eating two foods together is more beneficial than eating either food alone, is a rapidly advancing field [8].The concept, however, seems to have been in practice for a long time.For example, since ancient times, people in every culture have eaten some combination of beans and grains, the proteins from which are complementary in terms of amino acids [9].Plant foods contain the full complement of essential amino acids, but at varying levels.It is also well known that curcumin, the bioactive compound present in turmeric root, has a limited bioavailability if consumed alone in tablet form [10]. On the other hand, its absorption is greatly enhanced if eaten together with black pepper [11] or yogurt [12] or in curry form [13].The antioxidant property of oat phenolics is synergistically improved by ascorbic acid [14].A combination of tomato and broccoli was shown to be more effective at slowing tumor growth than either tomato or broccoli alone [15].Finally, evidence is accumulating that specific combinations of phytochemicals may offer better protection against cancer than single compounds (see Ref [16] for review).Eventually, as the knowledge regarding the interactions of various foods is expanded, the underlying mechanisms will be elucidated.Ultimately, as guidebooks map the food-food-body interactions (what may be referred to as "food interactomics"), intelligent diversified diets with targeted objectives can be developed.

Comparative view of a diverse diet vs. traditional diets
Considering food synergy, a well-planned and diversified diet will likely have health benefits over time [8].If this is the case, one may speculate about the health benefits of a diverse diet in comparison with the health effects of well-known dietary models, such as mediterranean, asian, and western diets [17].There may exist as many ethnic dietary or culinary models as the number of regions, perhaps even as many as the number of countries in the world.Each such diet may have signature foods unique to a region that offer distinctive health benefits and/or contribute to particular health issues.Existing dietary models have evolved over hundreds or thousands of years for a variety of historical, geographical, and cultural reasons, and thus each such diet has its favored foods.In contrast, one could envision a programmatic diversified diet consisting of a broad food portfolio.Analogous to a diversified financial portfolio, the varied diet is predicted to outperform existing dietary models in health benefits over time.To my knowledge, no specific diversified diet has ever been devised or tested vis-à-vis the classical dietary models.The proposed comparisons should open avenues of research asking for a variety of testable questions seeking to provide answers not only in terms of available laboratory tests such as cardiovascular markers, but also personal happiness, quality of living, long-term health benefits, and the consequent overall health care costs.

Figure 1 :
Figure 1: Concept of food circles.Each circle represents a separate food, as it enables application of the power of a Venn diagrammatic approach to visualize the complementarities/ synergies of a diversified diet.Removal of the stippled lines transforms Figure 1a into Figure 1b.See the body of the article for description of the dietary effects of this approach.